TT Epaper LHS
The Telegraph
TT Mobile
 
 
IN TODAY'S PAPER
WEEKLY FEATURES
CITY NEWSLINES
FEEDS
  RSS
  My Yahoo!
SEARCH
 
Archives Web
 
ARCHIVES
Since 1st March, 1999
 
THE TELEGRAPH
 
CIMA Gallary
 
Email This Page
Notice to govt on quota law

New Delhi, Jan. 31: The Supreme Court today issued a notice to the Centre on a petition seeking to strike down as unconstitutional the reservation for other backward classes in higher education institutions “established, maintained or aided” by the government.

Youth for Equality, an organisation of anti-quota activists, said in the petition that the quota law was enacted before the validity of the 93rd constitutional amendment, which empowers Parliament and state legislatures to bring such a law, was decided.

The petitioners argued that during the hearing of a plea challenging the validity of the 93rd amendment, it was “agreed and understood” that the government would not implement reservation without the court’s permission. But the government rushed to enact the law in January to provide for reservation from the 2007 session, it said.

The apex court has asked the Centre to respond.

The law was drafted without any survey or data on backwardness or inadequacy of representation or opportunity, the petition said. It added that the bill was politically motivated, having been passed with an eye on the upcoming Uttar Pradesh elections.

It should be struck down as it was “inconsistent and in derogation’’ of the right to equality and other fundamental rights, Youth for Equality said. The legislation would not stand the test of law as it provided for blanket reservation without excluding the “creamy layer” among the OBCs, the petition added.

The central quota law is, however, not the first passed after the 93rd amendment. Tamil Nadu had led the way with one of its own. A petition challenging the state law is pending before the court.

The validity of these laws would be looked into individually only if the petition challenging the validity of the 93rd constitutional amendment is dismissed.

Top
Email This Page

 More stories in Nation

  • Mamata seeks Somnath scalp
  • Sonia walks, not CPM
  • Amar counts 44, EC 2
  • Party swings to sound of twin slaps
  • Thus spake the law book
  • Singh mulls all-party meet
  • 'Firm' BJP outwitted
  • Profit and loss account
  • 'Mother' shocks Rae Bareli
  • Madan fells the wrong one
  • Yechury basks in Nepal glory
  • Industry begins caste count
  • Profit heat on Centre
  • Oil scam probe gets more time
  • US plans Asian power pipeline
  • Record win for Azad
  • Cop summons
  • Where's the data, SC asks govt
  • Arjun sorry about force, not quota
  • Akhilesh on cycle raring to take on Rahul
  • Pramod wife, son quizzed
  • Sonia mulls middle path
 
 
 
Biz2Credit Bizsense