TT Epaper LHS
The Telegraph
TT Mobile
 
 
IN TODAY'S PAPER
WEEKLY FEATURES
CITY NEWSLINES
FEEDS
  RSS
  My Yahoo!
SEARCH
 
Archives Web
 
ARCHIVES
Since 1st March, 1999
 
THE TELEGRAPH
 
CIMA Gallary
 
Email This Page
Drama over, stage waits
- Mamata storms out of meet
CPM leader Subhas Chakraborty (circled, left) and Mamata Banerjee (circled, right) at the all-party meeting at Mahajati Sadan on Thursday. To Mamata’s right is Forward Bloc leader Ashok Ghosh. Picture by Amit Datta

Calcutta, May 24: Genocide on her lips, Mamata Banerjee burst out but not before spending 1 hour and 51 minutes in a rainbow row of leaders rarely seen on the Bengal political horizon.

Neither Mamata nor the CPM sees it as the end of the road after the Trinamul Congress leader walked out of today’s all-party meeting convened to bring the homeless back to Nandigram.

The regulation rhetoric and accusations — largely centred on whether the deaths in the police firing should be dubbed “genocide” or not — notwithstanding, both sides were willing to join the next round of talks.

Neither had really expected the first round of talks to yield results on the ground. The leaders — Mamata, CPM’s Shyamal Chakraborty and Forward Bloc’s Ashok Ghosh —played down the initial failure, hoping to do better next time.

Mamata during the meeting and after the walkout. Pictures by Amit Datta

Going back from Mahajati Sadan to her Kalighat residence, Mamata said: “I have no problems attending a thousand meetings if they are convened by Ashok Ghosh, the RSP or the CPI. But the meeting must have a concrete agenda. We want peace in Nandigram but cannot stay in a meeting where CPM leaders justify the March 14 police firing and subsequent genocide.”

Mamata made the political point she wanted to make: she had attended a meeting called with a humanitarian objective while the CPM top brass stayed away.

This is the first time Mamata is attending any meeting with CPM leaders, though she took care not to sign the attendance register. On earlier occasions, she had sent other leaders to all-party meetings, either at political or administrative levels.

This time, Mamata attended the meeting with the sole intention of raising the Nandigram issue, demanding that the March 14 police firing in which 14 people died be described as “genocide’’.

Failing to extract the semantic surrender from the Left following vehement protests from the CPM representatives who included Subhas Chakraborty, she left the venue at 4.56 pm. She had stepped into the hall at 3.05 pm.

“Declaration of the Nandigram incident as genocide, punishment for the culprits involved, resumption of CBI inquiry, fixing responsibility on CID officials who failed to file chargesheets against the 10 arrested from Janani brick-kiln are my demands,’’ she said.

Later, fresh demands were laid down for any future meeting. It should have transparency; the meeting cannot be held if people at Nandigram spend each day at gun point; the Opposition should not be ridiculed; and the government should genuinely want to restore peace.

Today’s meeting started with convener Ghosh focusing on the need for a pro-people industrialisation drive. Mamata and the Congress’s Somen Mitra intervened and said the meeting should start with a reference to the March 14 police firing.

CPI minister Nandagopal Bhattacharyya read out a draft which the allies said was prepared as the “meeting ground’’ between the CPM and Mamata.

It said: “This meeting expresses grave concern over the situation in Nandigram and adjoining areas. This meeting also condemns the police firing and demands punishment to the culprits. It also demands compensation for the victims and asks the government to repair houses damaged during violence. The meeting demands an immediate end to the violence.”

Front sources said Bhattacharyya added another line to the draft to accommodate the CPM’s stand that “all sides will have to take the initiative to ensure punishment of those involved in the violence in Nandigram and its adjoining areas’’.

Top
Email This Page

 More stories in Front Page

  • Army keeps the babus off Brigade
  • One year of hope born in tragedy
  • Bid to open Nepal door
  • Mess of MP scheme
  • For good or bad, Brits just love Goa
  • Clerics tell rebels not to use Prophet's name
  • Textile scion charged with rape
  • More flak for forces in Manipur
  • Greatest one-day ever
  • Poultry farmer suicide
  • Parties warm to bill
  • Maoist error kills 13
  • Ambani ends power affair
  • Tura offices torched in protest
  • Burn victim
  • Steel showpiece in Calcutta
  • Nepal parties turn up pressure
  • Hope flickers for son Rahul
  • Praveen calm, plot fuzzy
  • Alert after attack on Sulfa
  • Writing is on the wall for revolution
  • tongue twister
  • Peace in the air, bullets fly
  • So long, old superspy in the sky
  • Dargah razed, lives lost
  • 'Second wife' and suicide bid follow Taliban terror
  • Ulfa salvo at AGP leaders
  • Priyanka in poll punch-up
  • Quota raises IIM exodus fear
  • Mob fury over surrender
  • Panel suggests Budhia go-slow
  • Ayurveda with Ash? Massage is on
  • Fine wine and dine
  • CAB poll elevated to battle in CPM
  • Blame pit fall on man and mouse
  • Jaswant to lift veil on 'mole'
  • Court admits PIL on mining
  • Major, rifleman guilty in Ajit custody death
  • Head turner goes reeling
  • 3-way race for cricket rights
  • Cash reward for Khasi mother of 17
  • Militants mock security rejig
  • Socialist in Senate
  • Till debt do us part: home truths
  • Reward for bearing 17 children
  • Buddha's wisdom for IIM
  • Way out of IT strike in sight
  • Peon doles out PhD degrees
  • Patna college teacher killed
  • Short shrift to the dead
  • Iron hand in Koda war on Maoists
  • Feuding factions rock peace boat
  • Court rap on Mizoram govt for paying rebels
  • Back to politics after punch-up
  • Inside story: outsiders who foxed Mamata
  • A curse gains star power
  • Track II move on Ulfa talks
  • Lashkar tentacles in Manipur
  • Burnt alive, says post-mortem
  • Dasham puts House on boil
  • Greg at ease with Ganguly
  • DEFY BANDH
  • Gangrape slur on Godda cops
  • Mishap for meet-bound CM
  • Ulfa strike on trader convoy
  • Tech schools flunk test
  • On a roll, the Roger I know
  • Petrol panic in strike-hit city
  • Germs to gobble train stain
  • Mature House in order
  • Death shock on terrace
  • Police hunt for medic duo
  • Broken vow led to killing
  • No change in NSCN truce rules
  • Team India's, onus Greg's
  • Tell-all hint in Bob email
  • Koda tests water in Delhi
  • Shun-force plea from Amnesty
  • Agni III test-fire achieves milestone
  • Docs reject Dispur pill for Ulfa wives
  • Fee on agri-malls
  • Dance relief,
  • Haste lands IIMs in admission muddle
  • Airline at a discount
  • Students shine, government blind
  • Room crunch clouds hover over sports event
  • Father throws 4-yr-old into river
  • Cops killed in dacoity drama
  • Quit notice looms over migrants
  • Bills unpaid, treatment stops
  • Refund door ajar for IIMs
  • MPs under trafficking cloud
  • Shunted for calling Antony 'shorty'
  • Indian blogger puts racial foot in the mouth
  • DGP stays away from court
  • SIM card seller in Masjid probe
  • Intruder hand in high-rise fatal fall
  • Wheels of terror travel
  • Release hope for engineer
  • Tide turns in engineered JEE
  • Army scraps career cell
  • A Mighty Heart, with a heavy heart
  • Terror boards Howrah train
  • Rebels focus on recruitment, Centre plans intelligence rejig
  • Red makes HC entry
  • Toddler rescued, on way home
  • Sparks of nuke hope
  • Thai tourism lecture
  • Gujjar warning
  • Strong-arm shadow on loan death
  • Reborn: Kashmir campus politics
  • Nuclear talks go under cover
  • Budhia torture slur on coach, cuffed
  • Five dead in Deoghar
  • Finger at dust in AC duct
  • Ulfa duo held in Punjab
  • Police halt carnage rerun
  • Nuclear noises hit high decibel
  • A matter of taste
  • Unsung Newtons of India
  • Sinking? Just grab a bench
  • SC holds back Vedanta verdict
  • Security tips build army friendship
  • Palamau girl wins varsity poll
  • Pupils riot for 'rights' on capital street
  • Office hint at project on right track
  • N-E carrot dangled in Big Apple investment drive
  • Fresh floods in Assam, 2 dead
  • Traders held for Ulfa link
  • Right to home for parents
  • Northeast goes to New York
  • Water panic in Howrah
  • India in final
  • Ticket to fly: When in California, cover up
  • Worst Dar comes true
  • Water hope for state by 2008 end
  • Assam basks in 5-star warmth
  • Demoralised rebels quit
  • Insiders prick CM
  • Scam of lakhs in Sikh riot relief
  • US betrays impatience
  • Hush hunt for 'suicide note'
  • Bomb defuses Mary and Maxi
  • Pressure but not lethal: Priyanka
  • Arson at Assam rail station
  • Cong puts rift blame on 'meddling' Soren
  • Puri temple in Hindu gaffe
  • Soldiers and people in land war
  • Freedom fighter home, a lifetime too late
  • 'When Priyanka asked Rizwanur to wait, he agreed'
  • Force file with PMO
  • To Russia, with nuclear reactor love
  • Bullets in turf war, potshots in party